The College of New Rochelle — A 115-Year-Old College Undone By Its Own Books

The College of New Rochelle, a private college in New Rochelle, New York, founded in 1904 as the first Catholic women’s college in the state, closed in the summer of 2019 after a financial concealment that its own trustees did not discover until the man responsible had already retired. It was, by the end, a secular-operating institution serving a substantially adult and minority student body, much of it through a network of branch campuses in New York City. Roughly 3,000 students were enrolled when the board announced, in February 2019, that the college would not survive the year.

The mechanism was not the familiar enrollment cliff but a fraud. The college’s longtime controller, Keith Borge, had for years failed to pay over more than $20 million in federal and state payroll taxes while falsifying the college’s financial statements to hide the hole. When he retired in 2016 and trustees brought in outside accountants, the investigation surfaced roughly $31 million in misappropriated funds and concealed liabilities — unpaid taxes, a drained endowment, federal grant money spent on operating costs, donations counted twice. Borge pleaded guilty in 2019 to securities fraud and failure to pay over payroll taxes and was sentenced to three years in prison. By then the institution could not be saved.

What followed was, by the grim standards of the closure era, a comparatively humane landing. Mercy College — a larger neighbor in Westchester and the Bronx — entered a teach-out agreement in March 2019, registered nearly 1,700 New Rochelle students for the fall, made offers to roughly 70 faculty and staff, leased three of the campuses, and took custody of the alumni transcripts and history. The College of New Rochelle held its final commencement on August 20, 2019, ceased operations, and entered Chapter 11 bankruptcy in September with some $80 million in liabilities.

What was lost was not only an institution but a particular kind of access. The School of New Resources had been built in 1972 expressly to bring a liberal-arts degree to working adults who had been shut out of one; its students were disproportionately Black, Latino, and older than the traditional undergraduate. They did not run the college’s books, and they had no warning of what was on them. The dry edge of this story belongs to the concealment — a single officer who falsified the ledgers of a 115-year-old college for years. The students belong to the sober part.