New College of California — A Radical College That Lost Its Accreditation and Then Itself

New College of California, a small progressive college in San Francisco’s Mission District founded in 1971, ceased operating in early 2008 after its regional accreditor moved to strip its accreditation and the U.S. Department of Education cut off its access to federal student aid. It was, for most of its life, exactly the institution it set out to be: an activist, humanities-centered alternative college with a law school dedicated to public-interest practice, programs in poetics and women’s spirituality, and a faculty that at various times included figures of the American left. It trained progressive lawyers and writers and organizers for nearly four decades. Then governance and money failed it, and the bodies that certify a college as a college withdrew their certification.

The decline was long and, by the end, fully documented. The Western Association of Schools and Colleges (WASC) had warned New College repeatedly across decades — over curriculum, governance, and finances — and in the summer of 2007 launched an investigation that found serious, long-standing deficiencies across every area it reviewed and placed the college on probation. By late 2007 the college was losing tens of thousands of dollars a month, had stopped paying faculty, and let health benefits lapse. After discovering record-keeping and financial-aid improprieties, the Department of Education placed New College on heightened cash monitoring and then, in early 2008, revoked its eligibility for federal aid — the financial oxygen a tuition-dependent college cannot live without.

The end was not a clean closing date but a quiet asphyxiation. Spring classes that were supposed to begin in mid-January 2008 were postponed and then never really started; with federal aid frozen, there was no money to run a semester. WASC revoked the accreditation in February 2008, and the college simply stopped functioning. The most viable parts were transplanted: the law school’s students moved to John F. Kennedy University in April 2008, and the women’s spirituality master’s program migrated to a graduate institute in Palo Alto. What remained was debt, unpaid staff, and a building on Valencia Street that had been, for a generation, one of San Francisco’s training grounds for the activist left.

New College’s story is not the demographic enrollment cliff that would claim so many small colleges a decade later. It is an older, plainer failure: a mission-driven institution whose internal governance and financial controls decayed until the external authorities that vouch for a college could no longer do so. When accreditation goes, federal aid follows, and for a college that lives on tuition, that is the end.